top of page

Exploring “You Can See Everything”: more questions than answers

14 hours ago
5 min read
Art by Winter Ryu-Whitney
Art by Winter Ryu-Whitney

(This article contains spoilers for You Can See Everything)


It’s no secret that Nathan Fielder works in a way that can’t be matched. His thinking is so bizarre, it’s hard to imagine how he gets the ideas for any of his projects. When I learned he was making a documentary, I imagined what I’m used to from him: awkward interactions, simulations of everyday life, mind-boggling situations that force one to wonder what is going on in his mind. The most interesting part of You Can See Everything is the idea that your opinion and takeaways are completely subjective, and no two people have the same view afterward. 


Having been raised on Fielder’s other projects, I’m well acquainted with his style: chili-filled suits, convincing a child that he is his father, learning how to fly a commercial airplane. It’s safe to say his story, as well as the story of Holmes, are worth a deep dive of their own if you’re unfamiliar. All I knew about Elizabeth Holmes before this movie was that she’s the founder of Theranos, the company that scammed investors and patients by delivering false test results. In my opinion, that’s all anyone really needs to know before watching this movie. After the movie, if you have questions— which you likely will— research as much about her as you’d like. It’s an interesting story. In my mind, this movie can be broken down into three chapters: the expected, the reveal, and the escalation. The first hour of the movie is exactly what is advertised in the trailer. The rest–not so much. The beauty of this film is that no two people will have exactly the same takeaways, and they'll likely be left with more questions than answers by the end.


The first scenes of the film immediately convey an uncomfortable dynamic between Fielder, Holmes, and Billy, the infamous husband. As we get a glimpse into Liz’s house, we notice a figure lurking in the corner who is just as confused as we are: The Dumb Starbucks creator himself. The audience, of course, goes wild. The film constantly circles back to an unsettling motif of eyes. Filming anyone close enough to see their pores is disturbing enough, but this technique really demonstrates that Holmes isn’t what she sees. Then, the cut to Nathan’s face, furrowed brow and all, contrasts Liz’s piercing blue eyes. Something is very wrong here, but we can’t tell what. The eyes are the key to the soul, and Liz is hiding something.


I didn’t even pick up on her submissiveness act until it was pointed out to me. Obviously she’s trying to look natural, which isn’t working very well, but she makes herself look helpless through Billy. When she’s making scrambled eggs, it looks like she’s mixing them weakly, barely trying– I wonder if this was intentional. Then, her hero Billy comes over and mixes them for her, laughing and telling Nathan that she can’t do it herself. This segment stood out to me as odd because of its fake nature; the scene pretends to be something it isn't. Regardless of whether Holmes is acting weak or not, she isn't entirely truthful— an early reminder that she isn't what she seems.


Watching these two characters interact was fascinating and frustrating, and each new word Holmes said left me bewildered and concerned. After many strange interactions, I thought the movie had come to an end. Then “Three Years Later” flashes on the screen, and I realized I was only one-third of the way through. Next, Amanda Seyfried appears on camera. Watching in the theater, maybe the biggest gasp occurred here. What struck me was the differences between the three main characters’ eyes. While Fielder’s close-ups are alarming and strange, and Holmes’ close-ups are empty with little emotion, Seyfried has a light in her eyes that contrasts her emotion-filled irises with the blindingly bright blue in Holmes’ eyes. It’s astonishing the little truth found in such pure, bright eyes, and how the truth we recognise is those eyes begging to be something they’re not; Amanda wants to be taken at face value, unlike Liz, who uses all her strength to keep it together.


The third and final part of this movie breaks all barriers and launches us into the final stage. Seyfried and Fielder recreate scenes not captured on camera, in true Rehearsal fashion. At a partly hilarious, partly disturbing dinner, Amanda and Nathan go to Billy’s house and question him about Liz. Billy doesn’t admit to exploiting Liz, but the contrast of him being a good father and a manipulator rings highly ironic. In between rounds of complimenting Charlie Kirk and making digs at Seyfried’s personal life, Billy tucks his kids into bed and acts the part he wants to play for the camera. Similar to Holmes, the lines are unclear between what is real and an act, and it disturbed me how fast he could switch personalities.


Eventually, Nathan puts together that Billy is letting people use Liz’s pictures without her consent, posting tweets from her account, and maybe worst of all, has power of attorney over her. Towards the end, the narrative, and especially the narrator’s view, shifts. When Nathan realizes that he has to see Liz in person to have a truthful conversation with her, he makes a plan to visit her in prison, without Billy realizing. However, with no recording allowed in the building, he would be unable to recount any of the conversation verbatim, yet he seems to give a detailed retelling of his conversation to Seyfried. At this point, he has become completely unreliable as a narrator; her deception worked on him, and his defense of her only gives the audience reason to question them both. In a way, this feels like the point. Nathan could be purposely telling the viewer that he has been convinced by her, or leaving it up for interpretation. The flashbacks to him swimming with her in the ocean further emphasise his submission to her tactics. He lets himself get roped into the narrative, sacrificing integrity to make a point, emphasizing his and Oppenheim’s genius even more. 


Final Thoughts

It’s so interesting that everyone has different takeaways and views of who was in the wrong. Right after the movie ended, I felt pretty bad for Liz. It genuinely seemed like Billy was in the wrong and she had been controlled by him. Until you start to think about the movie and realize her position of powerlessness was the point. Fielder is an unreliable narrator. He gets roped into her lies and falls in love with her. In the 3rd chapter, as Seyfried shows, he starts changing his memories to give her the benefit of the doubt. While I do have to recognise that Elizabeth was only three months postpartum during filming and her brain was likely scattered, it doesn’t erase the strange decision that she (or Billy) made to invite an entire filming crew into their home just before sending Liz to prison. 


Admittedly, my first thoughts coming out of this movie weren’t very positive. Lots of reviews that I saw online said that this movie would change all films forever and the entire industry as we know it. To me, in some ways, it just feels like a sequel to The Rehearsal, with a lot of the film feeling like it could’ve moved faster. When Billy’s faults begin to unravel, I was disgusted with him, but it didn’t feel super surprising. I think You Can See Everything is best enjoyed with other people to gasp and be confused with. There are so many details to unpack and subtleties that make it all the better to discuss and think about. The best parts of this movie happened long after it ended and after I processed what I saw.



Comments


bottom of page