Updated: 20 hours ago
If you’re at all familiar with the streaming platform Twitch, then you’re probably also familiar with the Dream SMP and its gaggle of popular streamers. If you’re unfamiliar, then let me fill you in: the Dream SMP is a Minecraft server named for and run by YouTuber Dream (dreamwastaken on Twitch) that focuses mainly on roleplaying and storylines involving the SMP’s members. The SMP features prominent streamers such as TommyInnit, Tubbo, Karl Jacobs, Wilbur Soot, Ranboo, and Nihachu, and Captain Puffy.
Recently, Captain Puffy has been getting more attention for being the most subscribed to female streamer on Twitch. This struck me as odd when I first heard it, not because Puffy and her content aren’t entertaining - I actually like Puffy a lot - but because, from what I remembered from the last Puffy stream I’d watched, she was fairly behind in subs compared to some of her Dream SMP peers.
That’s understandable, I figured at first. After all, there are creators on the SMP far more popular than Puffy (Quackity, Ranboo, and TommyInnit, to name a few) who have very dedicated fanbases; that might have accounted for the large gap in subscribers.
Just to be safe, I checked TwitchTracker.com which, among other things, tracks the number of active subs that Twitch streamers have. I was unsurprised to find that Puffy wasn’t in the Top 3; I hadn’t expected her to be. Part of me did, however, expect for her to be in the Top 10 to 15, given that people were saying she’s the most subbed female streamer on Twitch. I didn’t find her there, though.
I did find her on page 3, in 42nd place. I’m sure you can imagine the crushing disappointment I felt when I learned that the most subbed female streamer on Twitch was in 42nd place overall. Not only was I disappointed, but I was also angry. So, so angry. Livid, even. We’re in 2021, for God’s sake, and there’s not a single female streamer in the Top 10? The Top 20? Not even the Top 40? Why the HECK not?!
Of course, I know why not: Twitch has a misogyny problem.
That’s nothing new; lots of women on the platform, especially more prominent women, are specifically targeted by certain viewers to receive consistent hate while a majority of the men skate by unscathed. Now, I’m not going to do a deep-dive into Twitch’s history with misogyny, because if I did, we’d probably be here for two and a half weeks (food and bathroom breaks hopefully included), and nobody has that kind of time.
It is important to bring up, though, because, at the end of the day, misogyny is the real reason that more female streamers - and Puffy specifically - don’t have greater numbers of subs. After all, they’re women, fewer people take them and their content seriously, which means fewer people are likely to watch and enjoy their content, which means fewer people are talking about it, which means that fewer people who would enjoy their content get to learn about it. Of course, there are many factors at play when it comes to how many subscribers a Twitch streamer has, namely how often they stream and the fact that it costs money to subscribe to channels on Twitch, but come on; it’s so painfully obvious that this isn’t a coincidence.
It’s important to note that since I began writing this article, Puffy has done two “subathon” streams, which are event streams that creators hold to encourage viewers to subscribe to their channel. These subathons boosted her sub count to about a hundred under 15,000, but this increased effort only moved her up to 41st place. Luckily, though, as of March 12, 2021, Captain Puffy is in 32nd place!!